TALE OF THE TAPE

Tale Of The Tape: New York Giants At Carolina Panthers

New York Giants
Carolina Panthers
giantscredit2.jpg
pantherscredit.jpg
Quarterback
Winner It’s been a troubling start of Eli Manning since he has thrown seven touchdowns in the first two weeks of the season. The instinct is to protect this two-time Super Bowl winner, but he has not been on the same page as his receivers. While he’s certainly capable of turning it around, Manning is not throwing the ball well enough at this point.
Winner Cam Newton is quickly coming to a critical juncture in his career. While he has wonderful physical gifts, he has a hard time coming through with clutch plays for the Panthers. This team regularly falls short in the fourth quarter and that is largely on his shoulders for not finishing drives. Newton seems to feel the pressure in clutch situations and that’s troubling to head coach Ron Rivera.
Offense
Winner The Giants were under the impression that explosive David Wilson would give the Giants a plus running game this season, but his fumbling problem caused the team to bring back Brandon Jacobs. The Giants have a superb receiver in Victor Cruz, and Hakeem Nicks can stretch the field. The Giants’ offensive line is going to have an advantage in most games.
Winner The Panthers have the weapons to be a dangerous offensive team, but they don’t always play like it. DeAngelo Williams has some explosive characteristics and he is capable of busting long plays. Greg Olsen is one of the best receiving tight ends in the league, while Ted Ginn has the explosive speed to get downfield frequently. Steve Smith is still a game-changing factor.
Defense
The Giants did a solid job early in the game against Peyton Manning in Week Two, before the bottom fell out in the second half. The Giants have struggled on defense since the final eight games of last season and they have shown no signs of improving. Jason Pierre-Paul has not been on top of his game and the defensive line no longer gets after the quarterback the way it had in the past.
Winner The Panthers had all but secured a win over the Bills in Week Two, but linebacker Luke Kuechly’s pass interference penalty with 14 seconds left gave Buffalo a chance to steal the game, which it did. The Carolina defense allowed the Bills to score on four of their last six possessions. Despite the penalty, Kuechly is likely the Panthers best defensive player. He had 14 tackles vs. Buffalo.
Special Teams
Winner If the Giants are going to turn things around this year, they could get a lift from their special teams. Josh Brown made 3-of-3 FG attempts vs. the Broncos and is dependable while Steve Weatherford is a dependable punter. Wilson is capable of breaking big returns and giving his team a field-position boost.
Winner Brad Nortman has one of the biggest legs in the league. He average 51.4 yards on his punts against the Bills. Graham Gano made 3-of-3 FG attempts in that game, but he is just an average kicker. Ginn may be the most dangerous of all the return specialists in the league because of his speed.

The Winner Is

pantherscredit.jpg
Winner Carolina Panthers
4 out of 4

Brad Nortman has one of the biggest legs in the league. He average 51.4 yards on his punts against the Bills. Graham Gano made 3-of-3 FG attempts in that game, but he is just an average kicker. Ginn may be the most dangerous of all the return specialists in the league because of his speed.
-Steve Silverman, CBS Local Sports contributor

MORE TALES OF THE TAPE

  1. Frank Kaminsky #44 of the Wisconsin Badgers (Photo Credit: Mike McGinnis, Getty Images) Kaleb Tarczewski #35 of the Arizona Wildcats (Photo by Harry How/Getty Images)
    Elite Eight Tale: #1 Wisconsin Vs. #2 Arizona

    It is rematch time. Last year, the Wisconsin Badgers and Arizona Wildcats met in the Elite Eight and Wisconsin walked away with a 64-63 overtime win.

  2. Devin Booker #1 of the Kentucky Wildcats  (Photo by Gregory Shamus/Getty Images) Zach Auguste #30 of the Notre Dame Fighting Irish  (Photo by Andy Lyons/Getty Images)
    Elite Eight Tale: #1 Kentucky Vs. #3 Notre Dame

    Coming into the Sweet 16, West Virginia showed confidence that they could be the team that finally knocked off the Kentucky Wildcats.

  3. (Photo Credit: Grant Halverson, Getty Images) (Photo Credit: Gene Sweeney Jr., Getty Images)
    Sweet 16: #1 Duke Vs. #5 Utah

    So much for the weak Pac-12 this year: The Utah Utes are one of three teams from the beleaguered conference to make the Sweet 16 this year, and they’ll face the best ACC team left in the tournament: Duke.

See All Tales of the Tape