Bill Proposes Deferred Adjudication In DWI Cases

AUSTIN (AP) – A new legislative proposal would allow first-time drunken drivers in Texas to be acquitted if they complete supervision and treatment, a move supporters say would reduce court backlogs and shift the judicial system’s focus to punishing repeat DWI offenders.

Rep. Todd Smith, R-Euless, filed the proposal that would allow for deferred adjudication for first-time DWI offenders. Repetition of the offense would become grounds to increase future punishments.

The bill, which has supporters including Mothers Against Drunk Driving, prosecutors and defense attorneys, would be a change from the state’s stance that all drunken drivers should face fines and jail. In the mid-1980s, deferred adjudication for such offenses was abolished in the state. Opponents at the time, including MADD, had argued that the form of probation was being accepted for repeat offenders.

“It’s a needed change,” said Richard Alpert, a Tarrant County prosecutor. “It’s not like they are getting a free DWI, but a type of probation that would not technically be a conviction. If they don’t reoffend, they can say they have not been convicted. But if they do reoffend, it can be used to enhance their punishment.”

Supporters say that by routing cases out of courtrooms, the plan could ease court backlogs. Also, they say, it could improve efforts to track and punish repeat DWI offenders and remove the threat of jail that makes some first-timers refuse guilty pleas.

“Generally we do not support deferred adjudication bills, but we are going to support this one,” Bill Lewis, public policy liaison for the Irving-based nonprofit group MADD, told the Austin American-Statesman. “Right now, we are hearing that many cases are not getting prosecuted for DWI but for a bogus charge. We hope the practice of reducing charges will be reduced if this bill does indeed pass.”

Supporters of the bill also say it could give prosecutors a new negotiating tool.

Williamson County District Attorney John Bradley said that the plan would still require supervision of the defendant and could enforce fines and allow a judge to impose jail time as a condition of probation.

“This would be a first step to putting some sanity in that system as long as people make sure to retain it only for the true first-time offender,” Bradley said.

While the proposal has been in front of the Legislature before, Alpert said there is plenty of support this time.

“I think there is some momentum for this,” Alpert said. “It would give people who want to take responsibility an incentive to plead guilty, as opposed to setting these cases for trial. We have too many cases on the docket.”

(© Copyright 2010 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)


One Comment

  1. Bob Daggett says:

    I do not agree with this passing of this law !!! I was a victim of a DWI driver when I was 7 years old and still suffer side affects from this terrible night in my young life, I have also had to take medications all my life not to mention the hospital bills. What did this driver get for the misery I have suffered for 50+ years two tickets 1 for speeding and the second for running a read light. Now I ask you does this sound fair ? HELL NO !!!!!!!!!! Now they want to reduce the currant laws to let them off on probation? My opinion is that it will only add to the suffering of thousands of more people cause they got away with it once so they will try it again. So I feel this change in the laws is a big mistake, in fact I think even for a first time offender 60 days in jail is still to light of a punishment compared to what I have suffered all my life. I look back and see the youngster that was permanently crippled mentally and physically a year ago and he has to live the rest of his life like that and the parents that have to bear the blunt to care for this child. My heart goes out to them for the journey they have to face..

  2. trisha says:

    This would be great for first time offender, But for repeat offenders all they do is send them to prison where is the help do they not see there is a drinking problem, I know because my husband is in prison we begged the VA for help a long waiting list for men and women that served our country, When the vets in veitnam our goverment did not help them with mental Issues instead they came back feeling ashamed and you wonder what’s wrong help our men and women with Drinking problems prison is not the solution.

  3. Hemroidious says:

    Something has to be done. Too many police officers are being arrested for Drunk Driving. Especially in Dallas and Fort Worth. They can’t be punished like other people.

  4. kunde says:

    Lots of excellent reading here, many thanks! I had been searching on yahoo when I uncovered your post, I’m going to add your feed to Google Reader, I look forward to much more from you.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Dallas / Fort Worth

Drip Pan: CBS Local App
Drip Pan: Weather App

Watch & Listen LIVE