Dallas Company Absorbed In Paper Towel Ad Fight

CINCINNATI (AP) – Procter & Gamble Co. has picked up backing for its challenges to paper towel advertising by Kimberly-Clark Corp.

The advertising industry’s self-regulatory body recommends changes in commercials for Viva and Scott paper towels that have possibly misleading messages about absorbency and thickness compared to P&G’s Bounty.

The National Advertising Division Council of Better Business Bureaus investigated the separate campaigns after challenges by Cincinnati-based consumer products maker P&G.

Dallas-based Kimberly-Clark says it disagrees with the findings, but will abide by the recommendations. The major paper towel competitors have been faced additional pressure from shoppers trading down to cheaper store and generic brands during the weak economy.

In one challenged ad, “Sandy” has a team ready to use a giant roll of Viva towels to ram into a consumer’s home. Sandy holds up a self-help book and urges her to “Quit the Quilt,” referring to Bounty’s quilted towels and claiming they have more air, not thickness. The consumer then uses a Viva towel on a spill and is convinced.

The ad council, which studied consumer perceptions of the commercial, found that it communicates “that the use of quilted towels is a bad habit that should be broken by use of Viva towels, which provide more towel for the money.” The body said the ad messages that Viva is thicker or absorbs better aren’t supported.

Kimberly-Clark replied that the ads “merely encourage consumers, who are used to buying quilted towels, to consider trying Viva, a non-quilted alternative with important design and performance differences.”

The ad body also recommended changes to a commercial showing side-by-side cleanups after a children’s party that claims Scott towels “soak up everyday spills even faster than Bounty towels,” mainly because the ad depicts a five-minute absorption rather than immediate soaking up of the spill.

(© Copyright 2011 The Associated Press. All Rights Reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed.)


One Comment

  1. steve says:

    Wow ! Talk about slow news day !

  2. Katie says:

    Someone needs to look at making a towel that is not so linty. Have you ever noticed the lint bunnies on the counter under the paper towel holder? Or, the lint that is left on glass when cleaned with a paper towel? It wasn’t always that way.

  3. Steve says:

    Just stick to the Dollar Store Brand, No lint left on your counter or windows.

Comments are closed.

More From CBS Dallas / Fort Worth

Drip Pan: CBS Local App
Drip Pan: Weather App

Listen Live